An independent report has found quality is the public’s top priority when it comes to shaping the future of children’s congenital heart services. The report, compiled by independent experts, Ipsos MORI, on behalf of NHS Safe and Sustainable, provides a detailed analysis of more than 75,000 responses to a national consultation, one of the largest ever carried out by the NHS. The consultation included a large number of responses from the BME community (20% of total formal responses) and from children and young people (10% of total formal responses).
Safe-and-Sustainable-Consultation-Report
(large document that requires adobe)
During the consultation, which ran from 1 March to 1 July 2011, people were asked to share their views on the key principles of the review, four configuration options which would pool surgical expertise into fewer larger centres, the development of congenital heart networks to bring care closer to home and new national quality standards.
The report demonstrates strong support for the key principles of the review and nine out of ten support the proposed national quality standards. There was significant support for ensuring excellent care – of those who responded 93% of individuals and 94% of organisations support these standards. An extremely high number of respondents supported the proposal to improve the collection, reporting and analysis of mortality and morbidity data – of those who responded, 85% of both individual respondents and organisations agreed with this proposal.
There was a strong belief among many respondents that quality should be the deciding factor when planning future services. People were also positive about proposals to develop congenital heart networks that would deliver care closer to home – more than three quarters of both individual respondents and organisations supported this proposal. There was also significant support for the proposals that centres no longer providing surgery become children’s cardiology centres.
Option A – seven surgical centres
Freeman Hospital, Newcastle
Alder Hey Children’s Hospital, Liverpool
Glenfield Hospital, Leicester
Birmingham Children’s Hospital
Bristol Royal Hospital for Children
2 centres in London
Option B – seven surgical centres
Freeman Hospital, Newcastle
Alder Hey Children’s Hospital, Liverpool
Birmingham Children’s Hospital
Bristol Royal Hospital for Children
Southampton General Hospital
2 centres in London
Option C – six surgical centres
Freeman Hospital, Newcastle
Alder Hey Children’s Hospital, Liverpool
Birmingham Children’s Hospital
Bristol Royal Hospital for Children
2 centres in London
Option D – six surgical centres
Leeds General Infirmary
Alder Hey Children’s Hospital, Liverpool
Birmingham Children’s Hospital
Bristol Royal Hospital for Children
2 centres in London
London – The preferred two London centres in the four options are:
Evelina Children’s Hospital
Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children
Option A was the option selected by more individuals than any other, although more organisations supported Option B. As anticipated, support for configuration options was strongly influenced by where people live. There were high levels of responses from people in the East Midlands and South Central regions. Option B was the most widely supported option across the country as a whole, excluding these regions.
Option C received very little support and whilst support for Option D was strong in Yorkshire and Humberside, it received very limited backing elsewhere. Of those respondents who did not express a preference for an option, fewer than 300 people included all eleven centres in their preferred reconfiguration.
People were also asked for their views on the proposal that the number of surgical centres in London should be reduced from three to two. Around 75% of respondents supported this proposal. 47% of respondents from London supported the proposal for two centres; there was less support in parts of northern England with some people commenting that just one centre in London should suffice. The majority of those responding agreed that the proposed centres should be Great Ormond Street Hospital for Children NHS Trust and Evelina Children’s Hospital (Guy’s and St Thomas’ NHS Foundation Trust).
Sir Neil McKay CB, Chair of the Joint Committee of Primary Care Trusts, said:
I would like to thank everyone for giving us their views during the consultation. The scale of the response confirms to me the importance of ensuring excellent NHS care for children with congenital heart disease. I am heartened by the overwhelming support for the quality standards which are the bedrock of the Safe and Sustainable programme. Implementing these new standards will improve the quality of care for children across England. The task for us now is to carefully consider the findings in detail along with other evidence before we reach final decisions later this year.
The report is one of a number of publications to be considered by the Joint Committee of Primary Care Trusts (JCPCT), the decision-making body. The JCPCT will also take into account a range of other data including Health Impact Assessments, analysis of family travel patterns and information about capacity planning provided by Trusts.
The JCPCT is expected to make a final decision by the end of 2011. Implementation of any changes to children’s congenital heart services is expected to start in 2013. A detailed implementation plan will be developed once a decision has been made.
A spokesman for Leeds Teaching Hospitals said today:
Given the way hospitals were grouped in the four options set out in the Safe and Sustainable consultation document it is by no means a surprise that support for Option D was largely confined to people from Yorkshire and the Humber.
During the consultation, at public meetings and other events, parents, families and the wider public as well as their representatives including MPs, councillors and charities, have spoken loud and clear and made a powerful and compelling case for keeping the service here in Leeds.
The level of support is demonstrated by the unprecedented 600,000-strong petition handed in to Downing Street in June supporting Option D to retain services at Leeds for the huge population living within two hours drive of the unit.
Clearly the Safe and Sustainable consultation has revealed there is a massive amount of public concern in this region about the prospect of children’s heart surgery being moved away from Leeds and the figures and report released today do not in any way change that.
